The term "margin" refers
to a brokerage firm making a loan to a customer using securities
held in the customer's account as collateral for the loan. There
are two basic reasons for a customer to use margin. The most
common is leveraged trading, allowing the purchase of a greater
number of shares on margin than would be possible on a cash
only basis. When successful investments are made, margin increases
the gains achieved. However, when poor investments are made,
the use of margin also magnifies the losses. Thus margin is
not appropriate for all investors. Investors with insufficient
skill or lacking the temperament that leveraged trading demands
should not use margin.
The second reason for utilizing margin is to take advantage
of the lower interest rates charged on margin loans than almost
any other type of loan. A typical example of this would be a
customer who has $40,000 worth of fully paid for securities
in his account that buys a new boat for $20,000. If he borrows
the money to purchase the boat from his bank, he will typically
pay several points over the prime lending rate. If he simply
borrows the money from his broker, he will typically pay less
than the prime rate, with no loan application to deal with and
with very flexible repayment terms.
BACKGROUND ON MARGIN ACCOUNTS
The rules, regulations and requirements regarding margin accounts
come from three sources:
- The Federal Reserve Board sets margin requirements as
part of monetary policy. These are collectively known as
FED REQUIREMENTS.
- Stock exchanges also set margin requirements that their
member firms are required to observe, and when the exchange
setting the requirement is the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE),
most or all firms observe the requirement, whether or not
they are a NYSE member firm. These are collectively known
as EXCHANGE REQUIREMENTS.
- Most brokerage firms also set their own margin requirements
more stringent than those of the Federal Reserve in order
to limit risk, much as lending practices vary from bank
to bank. These are collectively known as HOUSE
REQUIREMENTS.
Brokerage firms make money on margin accounts from the interest
charged on the loans and also from higher commissions on the
larger transaction sizes that leverage allows. However, lending
money carries risks for the brokerage firm similar to the risks
that banks face when lending, i.e.: the borrower may default
on the loan.
Since margin loans (represented in customer accounts as debit
balances) are always secured by the securities held as collateral,
the real risk is that the securities held in the margin account
will decline in value to a point where they are worth less than
the loan balance. True, the
margin agreement always makes
the customer legally liable for the balance, but some customers
are unable or unwilling to pay for something they know has no
value to them, thus the best preventive medicine that a firm
can employ is to never let customers have a debit balance in
their accounts that exceeds the liquidation value of their securities,
a condition referred to as an "unsecured debit" in an account.
When establishing a new margin account, the first requirement
that must be met comes from the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE),
but is universally applied to securities, regardless of whether
they trade on the NYSE or whether the firm is a NYSE Member
Firm. The NYSE requires brokerage firms to demand that investors
deposit a minimum of $2,000 in either cash or equity (paid for
marginable securities) in order to open a margin account. This
means that if you want to purchase $3,000 in stock, you will
have to deposit $2,000 of your money in order to borrow the
remaining $1,000. This in an example of an
exchange requirement,
and is an on going maintenance requirement for a margin account.
This means that the value of the customers equity can never
fall below $2,000 in a margin account.
A margin account must always have
$2000 in account holder equity to use margin provisions.
A new purchase in a margin account is also subject to the initial
requirement set by the Federal Reserve. This is the minimum
down payment required to buy stock on margin. The current initial
requirement is 50%. Thus, an investor wanting to purchase $10,000
worth of stock in his margin account must deposit at least $5,000
worth of equity into the margin account. This is an example
of a
Fed requirement.
Anyone who has taken accounting knows the basic accounting equation:
Equity = Assets - Liabilities
For margin investing, this equation changes slightly to:
Equity = Market Value
- Debit Balance
Stated another way, the equity in a margin account is equal
to what the securities could be sold for ( the market value)
less the amount of money borrowed on margin (the debit balance).
The account represented by the equation above holds securities
with a market value of $200,000. The investor has borrowed (and
therefore owes the brokerage firm) $100,000 (the debit balance).
Subtracting the amount borrowed from the value of the securities
gives the investor's equity of $100,000.
THE INITIAL REQUIREMENT
Let's begin with the example of a newly opened margin account
where the investor has signed all the paperwork but has not
yet sent in any money. For the first trade in the account, the
investor buys 100 shares of ABC at $75 per share.
Since the investor has not as yet paid for the purchase, his
equity is zero, and he owes the brokerage firm the entire purchase
price. All funds have been advanced on his behalf by the brokerage
firm. At this point, the account has a margin call of $3,750.00,
which is 50% of the purchase price (remember the 50% initial
requirement ?). Since this margin call comes by way of the Federal
Reserve requirement, it is also referred to as a Fed Call. The
investor must send in at least this much.
The investor sends in $5,000, which is more than the minimum
amount required.
The deposit of $5,000 reduced the debit balance in the account
to $2,500 ($7,500 - $5,000). The equity in the account is now
$5,000.
ABOUT MARGIN CALLS
A true "margin call" may be issued when an investor establishes
a
new long or short position. Although they are commonly
called margin calls, the type of call issued when the equity
in an account falls below a certain required level is actually
a maintenance call. These will be covered shortly but right
now we are only concerned with the initial minimum deposit requirement
(down payment). The Federal Reserve currently requires that
50% of the market value of any new purchases or short sales
must be deposited in a new margin account.
An established account may have sufficient buying power to satisfy
all or part of the requirement. If sufficient "buying power"
is available, issuing a margin call may not be required.
Proceed to the next lesson,
SMA (the
Special Memorandum Account) and Excess Equity.