Margin Requirements on Short Sales
In order to make it easier to track and monitor short sales
and positions, most brokerage firms execute and hold short sales
in the "short account." This is really just a sub-account of
a margin account since Regulation T requires all short sales
to be done in a margin account.
The Reg. T initial margin requirement on a short sale calls
for "150% of the short sale proceeds." This means that the entire
amount received from the proceeds of the sale
plus an
additional 50% of the proceeds is the initial margin requirement
on a short position.
|
Transaction Description
|
Share Price
|
Sale Proceeds
|
Reg. T 50% Requirement
|
Credit Bal. Retained
|
|
Short 100 shs. ABC
|
$50
|
$5000
|
$2500
|
$7500
|
|
Short 100 shs. DEF
|
$20
|
$20,000
|
$10,000
|
$30,000
|
|
Short 100 shs. KYZ
|
$90
|
$90,000
|
$45,000
|
$135,000
|
Since the final column amounts above are retention requirements
which providie collateral for the shares sold short, they cannot
be removed from the account. Thus, they are not free credit
balances and typically will not earn interest for the investor
since interest is usually paid only on free credit balances.
This cash is held in customer accounts, but any interest earned
is kept by the brokerage firm. This is why the stock loan department
of brokerage firms are very profitable.
The Reg. T initial margin requirement on a short sale is charged
against the Special Memorandum Account (SMA). In the event that
the SMA balance is insufficient to cover the charge, a margin
call is issued against the account. This Fed call must then
be met no later than the seventh business day, either by depositing
cash or marginable securities with a loan value at least equal
to the amount of the call.
The NYSE and NASD maintenance margin requirements are greater
on short positions than on long positions. Usually though, the
house requirements of various brokerage firms are more stringent
than the NYSE and NASD requirements. An investor should always
get a copy of the house margin requirements wherever he maintains
a margin account.
Let's look at what happens to the margin requirements on a short
position when the market price increases on the security sold
short. Suppose an investor sells 100 shares of ABC at $100 per
share. We'll use the following table to figure the initial margin
requirement.
|
Transaction Description
|
Share Price
|
Sale Proceeds
|
Reg. T 50% Requirement
|
Credit Bal. Retained
|
|
Short 100 shs. ABC
|
$100
|
$10,000
|
$5000
|
$15,000
|
Now, suppose that the price of ABC increases 20% to $120 per
share. We'll use the NYSE/NASD maintenance requirement of 30%
to calculate the maintenance margin requirement. In order to
meet the minimum maintenance requirement, there must be enough
credit in the special memorandum account to meet 100% of the
current market value plus another 30% of the current market
value. This procedure is known as marking to the market and
is used to ensure that the lender of the security will always
have 100% of the current market value of the security.
|
Current Share Price
|
100% of Current Market Value
Requirement
|
30% of Current Market Value
Requirement
|
Total Requirement
|
|
$120
|
$12,000
|
$3600
|
$15,600
|
In this example, the investor would have to meet a margin call
for an additional $600 based on only a 20% adverse move in the
stock price. This extra money is given to the lender to increase
his collateral. Let's continue the example and assume another
20% rise in the price of ABC.
|
Current Share Price
|
100% of Current Market Value
Requirement
|
30% of Current Market Value
Requirement
|
Total Requirement
|
|
$140
|
$14,000
|
$4200
|
$18,200
|
Thus, on the second 20% adverse move, the investor would have
to post $2,600, more than four times the amount required to
meet the first margin call.
When an investor buys a security, his theoretical losses are
limited to 100% because the stock cannot decline below $0.
When an investor sells a security short, his theoretical
losses can be infinite because the value of the underlying security
can keep on increasing.
Now let's use this same example to see what happens if the investor
is right and the stock price declines from the sale price of
$100 down to $90. A reverse mark to the market reveals the following:
|
Current Share Price
|
100% of Current Market Value
Requirement
|
30% of Current Market Value
Requirement
|
Total Requirement
|
|
$90
|
$9000
|
#4500
|
#13,500
|
In this example, the lender, who was originally holding $10,000
as collateral, would have to return $1,000 to the borrower,
so that the lender's collateral is maintained at 100% of the
current short market value (SMV) of $9,000. In addition, Reg.
T requires the short seller to maintain an additional 50% of
the SMV, or $4,500 in this instance. Thus, on a $1,000 decline
in SMV, $1,500 or 150% is released to SMA.
The formula used to find the dollar amount of equity in a short
position is:
|
Credit Balance
|
Minus
|
Short Market Value
|
Equals
|
Equity
|
After meeting the margin call in the last example above, the
investor has put up a total of $8,200 and his current equity
is:
|
$18,000
|
Minus
|
$14,000
|
Equals
|
$4200
|
The formula to determine the maximum value that the underlying
security can appreciate to before a margin call will be generated
is:
|
Total Credit Balance
|
Divided By
|
130%
|
Equals
|
Maximum Market Value Before
Call
|
Using our previous example when the sort sale was first made,
the highest ABC stock could have gone before a call was generated
would be:
|
$15,000
|
Divided By
|
$130%
|
Equals
|
$11,538.46
|
If ABC closed the trading day at $11 1/2 per share, no call
would be issued. If ABC closes the day at 11 5/8, a maintenance
margin call would be issued.